Pizza
Sally's Apizza
New Haven, Connecticut
Why stop here: Sally's Apizza is a $$ pizza pick in New Haven. Order Tomato pie with fresh mozzarella.
CuisinePizza
Price$$
TownNew Haven
Founded 1938 and run for decades by the Consiglio family, a coal-oven rival to Pepe's a block away.
What to order
Tomato pie with fresh mozzarella
At Sally's Apizza, Roamward highlights Tomato pie with fresh mozzarella because it gives travelers a clear first order instead of leaving the meal to guesswork. Use it as the anchor, then check the current menu before you go.
Updated July 2026. Restaurant hours, menus, and reservation policies change — confirm before you go.
Build a trip around New Haven dining stop.
Roamward turns spots like this into a real road trip on your phone — the scenic drive, the stops, and the detours, planned around the vibe you’re after. Get early access: